It’s been some time since I last provided a round up of the things I’ve come across that stuck with me, or found myself mulling over and wanting to share. For certain, the house hunt, purchase and move were a huge part of that but I also think I’ve had less mental space since my promotion in February to devote to things beyond cool vintage pictures or dresses that catch my eye. Feel free to send anything my way you think might fit in this type of post–I know I don’t hesitate to send Wendy B. random peacock dresses!
….
First, the potentially controversial bit. I wasn’t the only one pleasantly surprised by Lucky’s most recent issue devoted to all things affordable. This included a nice 2-3 page spread of various web sites that sell things someone besides Beyonce can afford. Etsy was on that list and I felt my face contort as I saw their 1 line description: a great site to buy things wholesale.
To sell handmade items wholesale is pretty much an oxymoron at heart. To sell wholesale means to provide a deep discount because the product is being sold in bulk. For some people, this is not unheard of; they determine a threshold (say, 20 items or a $200 limit) and provide a discount once that thresh hold is reached. When you sell items as one offs, however, providing that discount basically means you sell at a loss.
This topic gets covered pretty regularly in the Etsy forums. The people trying to make a living, or at least cover the cost of their time and materials, often express their frustration with other sellers they don’t feel price their items appropriately. Those sellers sometimes pipe up and say they’re just hobbyists. As a hobbyist myself, I can definitely see both sides of the coin.
DoubleX, however, threw some interesting wood on the fire with their recent article: Etsy.com Peddles a False Feminist Fantasy.
…what Etsy is really peddling isn’t only handicrafts, but also the feminist promise that you can have a family and create hip arts and crafts from home during flexible, reasonable hours while still having a respectable, fulfilling, and remunerative career. The problem is that on Etsy, as in much of life, the promise is a fantasy.
The writer has an amazing point that I don’t think many people would be willing to make…but her supporting arguments don’t strike me as true. Yes, it’s incredibly difficult to actually make a living selling handmade goods. A lot of wildly successful sellers are not in the one-off business (prints of original art work, for example) or they have help in the assembly of their goods. Etsy does little to suggest that this success is incredibly difficult to duplicate–and honestly, it’s in their best interest to refrain from making that clear.
However, to say that it’s a woman’s ghetto that men are savvy enough to avoid strikes me as belittling and truly off target. While a good portion of the sellers are moms, the majority I know are not. I don’t think being a mom and wanting to have a career is necessarily a huge driver for women looking to achieve a balance by selling handmade goods–obviously it can’t be since such a large portion of sellers don’t necessarily have children. If anything, I imagine it’s the fact that the average job isn’t 100% gratifying–and who isn’t striving for something better, a work day that is as satisfying as a weekend, a job that makes you feel good about yourself, and the luxury of setting your own hours? I know that was the temptation for me a year and a half ago when I was at my previous job. I honestly thought about going to 30 hours a week–but that was as far as my fantasy took me because I knew making a living was just not doable by selling online alone.
I came across this article via even cleveland and one of the very brief comments in response to the post struck me as very true:
Having a job that you love 100% is always a fantasy.
I truly hope to retire from the job I have now. But you can bet there are bad days and even bad weeks where my frustration can’t even find release in looking at kittens on Cute Overload. & I imagine that if I’d somehow become one of those wildly successful Etsy sellers, those same bad days and bad weeks would happen.
….
I gave away my dorkiness on Twitter not too long ago. The Sims is the only game I’ve ever enjoyed (I played a friend’s 1st version back in 2001 when only 12 outfits were available.) I’ve yet to pick up the latest version but this blog following two Sims the creator has made homeless was surprisingly fascinating. The fact that the characters actually develop characteristics (instead of acquiring skills) makes the arc that much more tragic–and uncannily similar to real life.

….
Dawn at Plush-a-holic is an insanely talented person who has an eye for finding creations that truly blur the line between art and craft (and who said such a line should exist anyways?) Leah Evan’s textiles definitely fall into that realm.

Having a passing familiarity with quilting, I have a deep admiration for those who have not only the time that it requires, but the creativity to do something new and interesting with the craft. My love of Susan’s geisha, cowboy and trompe l’oeil quilts is all the greater given the knowledge I couldn’t think of anything so neat. Leah’s quilts are an entire other matter. Like topography or road maps, the gorgeous, subtle colors don’t leap out right away. Their beauty is no less though and the detail is simply amazing.
11 Comments »